Wednesday, November 22, 2017
Stage

Review: Two incredible lead characters, plus excellent choral work and staging, make for superb 'Evita' at Stage West

RECOMMENDED READING


I often wonder if casual patrons of the musical Evita appreciate just how incredibly difficult the show is to perform. Andrew Lloyd Webber's eclectic music styles — classical, ballad, Latin, rock — lightning-fast tempo changes and sometimes atonal, non-melodic sing-throughs, paired with Tim Rice's information-packed lyrics, are a challenge to performers and listeners alike. It's a show that may take more than one viewing to comprehend.

The production at Stage West Community Playhouse in Spring Hill playing through Sunday, March 19, goes a long way toward making that easier, thanks to several knockout performances by director Dixie Lay's superb cast, dynamic accompaniment by music director Carol Brown's orchestra, fine choral work by a first-rate ensemble, period-perfect costumes by Eileen Bernard and (mostly) appropriate dances by choreographer Sydney Campo, plus a great set, lighting and sound design and execution by a close-knit team of Stage West stalwarts.

Foremost in the endeavor are Jennifer Agnelli, playing the title role of the controversial First Lady of Argentina from 1946 until her death at age 33 in 1952, and Jay Garcia as Che, the commentator/narrator. These two are on stage most of the time and are in great measure responsible for maintaining the timing and pace of the show. Both do exceptional jobs, having mastered the vocal gymnastics required to do the roles justice.

Agnelli is a seasoned professional who has performed with Broadway national tours, and it shows in her every utterance and move — graceful, controlled and emotional, her mezzo-soprano hitting every note with precision. Her Don't Cry For Me Argentina and Lament are heartbreaking. Her acting captures the vibrancy and passion of María Eva Duarte de Perón as she moves from being an illegitimate slum kid to becoming a famous actress and radio personality to, finally, the most powerful woman in the country, both as the wife of the president and for being herself, revered to this day by the great majority of Argentinians.

Garcia is doing his first lead role, but you would never know it. He is as confident as any old pro, striding around the stage, relaxing on the stairs, his body language on point, his face a mix of cynicism and admiration for Evita, his voice right on the money in Oh What a Circus, Good Night and Thank You, And the Money Kept Rolling In (And Out), and others. Both actors deserved the ovations they received opening night.

They are nicely supported by Brady Lay as the ambivalently ambitious Juan Perón — soldier, politician, lover and president; Lainey Poulis as Perón's mistress, her broken heart evident as she sings the sad Another Suitcase in Another Hall, and Charles Kleber as Augstin Magaldi, supposedly Evita's first love interest (though that's disputed by historians), crooning On This Night of a Thousand Stars and cautioning the naive young Evita to Beware of the City.

And kudos to the 20-member ensemble and their vocal coach. (Was it music director Brown?) They mastered the demanding Spanish lyrical chanting and moved about the stage smoothly, blending with the action and punctuating the most dramatic moments. The angelic voices of the children in Santa Evita were a joy to hear. The adagios by the uncredited couple during Act One set a romantic mood for the burgeoning romance between Evita and Juan.

The flaws are few — an over-enthusiastic percussionist at some points and a post-modern/contemporary dance sequence that doesn't seem to fit with the culture and era and goes on too long, even as Evita sings in the background.

That said, Stage West's Evita is a pleasure to hear and watch, showcasing the extraordinary talents of Broadway tour veteran Agnelli, heralding the elevation of Garcia as a candidate for any lead role in any show, and displaying a very impressive directorial debut for Lay.

This article has been revised to reflect the following correction: Carol Brown was the music director for Stage West Community Playhouse's production of Evita. The music director's name was reported incorrectly in a review published March 17.

Comments
‘Fun Home’ opens at the Straz, ‘The Little Prince’ at Freefall

‘Fun Home’ opens at the Straz, ‘The Little Prince’ at Freefall

LIFE AND DEATH: FUN HOMEEvery year, the Straz Center tries to mix it up a little, injecting a not-quite-so-safe show into an otherwise bankable lineup. Last year, that was The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time. This year it’s Fun Home, a ...
Published: 11/22/17
Powerstories’ latest production strikes a personal chord with founder

Powerstories’ latest production strikes a personal chord with founder

In the upcoming musical Twelve, Powerstories Theatre will present a holiday story revolving around a single mother who’s working as a waitress in 1950 San Diego.For Powerstories founder Fran Powers, the production represents an account she crafted fr...
Published: 11/21/17
Updated: 11/22/17
It’s a Doo Wop holiday at the Show Palace

It’s a Doo Wop holiday at the Show Palace

HUDSON — Music brings the Rudolph family together in A Doo Wop Christmas, which opens Saturday and runs through Dec. 25 at the Show Palace Dinner Theatre.This new production, directed by Peter Clapsis (The Great American Trailer Park Musical) with m...
Updated: 10 hours ago
What’s on stage this week: Benji Brown, ‘No Man’s Land’ on screen, Florida Orchestra does Bruch

What’s on stage this week: Benji Brown, ‘No Man’s Land’ on screen, Florida Orchestra does Bruch

KIKI OR BUST: BENJI BROWNWherever Benji Brown goes, Kiki follows. The comic, known for his work on the Rickey Smiley Morning Show, created the fast-talking female character on the fly when he called a girl’s house in high school and her boyfriend pic...
Published: 11/15/17
American Stage’s ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ is just what the love doctor ordered

American Stage’s ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ is just what the love doctor ordered

ST. PETERSBURG — A centuries-old template for the rom-com as we know it and one of Shakespeare’s most produced comedies, Much Ado About Nothing comes to us at a time when we can really use some love conquering all. Just what the love doctor ordered, ...
Published: 11/13/17
Updated: 11/15/17
Review: With a fine script, Stage West cast puts on a great show in ‘Baggage’

Review: With a fine script, Stage West cast puts on a great show in ‘Baggage’

Okay, I’ll admit I went into the Forum at Stage West Community Playhouse in Spring Hill on opening night of the comedy Baggage expecting another June/moon/spoon romance-comedy. And sure enough, that’s just the way it started.A man and a woman grab ea...
Published: 11/10/17
Updated: 11/16/17
From stickup to stand-up, bank robber's second act is comedy

From stickup to stand-up, bank robber's second act is comedy

TAMPA — He had dreamed about returning to comedy in odd moments, between meetings with the lawyer, the lonely trip to the correctional institute, picking up trash on state roads while a guard stood by with a rifle. This nightmare would make him...
Published: 11/10/17
Updated: 11/12/17
Sammy Hagar talks Clearwater concert, tequila and Van Halen drama

Sammy Hagar talks Clearwater concert, tequila and Van Halen drama

The Red Rocker calls on time, and he is all kinds of fired up."Hey, Jay, Sammy Hagar here. Are you ready for me?"Is anyone ever truly ready for a phone call from Hagar, the flame-haired, motor-mouthed ex-Van Halen singer who once dubbed himself the C...
Published: 11/09/17
Updated: 11/12/17
What’s on stage this week: ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ in Key West, Travis Wall Shaping Sound

What’s on stage this week: ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ in Key West, Travis Wall Shaping Sound

AMERICAN STAGE: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHINGTwo couples nearly come apart at the seams for different reasons, the premise for Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing, opening at American Stage. This version is set in Key West in the 1940s, the end of World Wa...
Published: 11/08/17
Updated: 11/15/17
Review: ‘The Year of Magical Thinking’ at Stageworks

Review: ‘The Year of Magical Thinking’ at Stageworks

At the beginning of The Year of Magical Thinking, Joan Didion acknowledges that the audience might not want to hear her story because we don’t think it could happen to us."It will happen to you," Didion says with a rueful smile, and of course she’s r...
Updated one month ago