Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Low grades temper Dade City mother's enthusiasm over son's honor roll performance

DADE CITY — Beth Tillack was beside herself.

She had taken away computer and iPod privileges from her son, Douglas, for poor grades in his civics class at Pasco Middle School. Yet, when report cards came out, Tillack learned her seventh-grader's overall grade-point average had landed him on the honor roll.

He needed a 3.15. His grades — four A's, a C and a D — averaged out to 3.16.

"I am furious and appalled," Tillack wrote to superintendent Kurt Browning. "Talk about minimum standards! So now instead of losing privileges and trying harder, he now thinks he has done enough. I am so shocked."

She didn't expect anyone to understand her concern. But to her surprise, Browning and his staff took her side and demanded answers.

"I am with the parent on this one," assistant superintendent Amelia Larson said in an e-mail to Browning.

For too long, Larson said in an interview with the Tampa Bay Times, education has focused on grades as an end in themselves. Parents and students often get upset about B's, not to mention D's and F's, because good marks serve as a gateway to other positive things in life.

"We want a better way of communicating progress toward our end-of-the-year outcomes so parents don't get upset if their kids don't come home with straight A's," Larson said. "If we give the wrong message, the kids may be content at the level they are at."

She cited the influence of Stanford psychologist Carol Dweck, an expert on motivation, on her own philosophy for the district. Dweck's "growth mind-set" theory — that students do best if they believe their intelligence can improve through experience and experimentation — is gaining wider acceptance in K-12 education around the country.

"You don't do kids any favors if we're not honest, if we inflate their achievement or we put it down," said Ken O'Connor, a Canadian education consultant who specializes in student grading and reporting.

Letter grades are "virtually worthless" without detailing areas that need improvement or areas that show improvement, O'Connor said.

Schools and society place too much emphasis on grades as a credential, said Columbia University education sociologist Aaron Pallas.

Letter grades lack subtleties of what students, parents and teachers need to do to get the desired results, Pallas said. Sometimes, that means praising struggling students so they feel a sense of accomplishment, even if they don't meet all of the standards. Sometimes, it means making lessons more interesting.

And if parental priorities get lost in school procedures, Pallas said, all need to collaborate.

"I think talking is the best thing," he said.

Tillack found that reaching out to Pasco Middle School yielded just such a relationship.

Principal Kim Anderson reviewed the report card with Douglas, pointing out areas where he needed to work harder, without discounting the fact that he had done well in the majority of his courses. His teachers also reacted positively, Tillack said.

They found that Douglas simply found civics uninteresting.

"The dilemma is, how can we work together to motivate a child who has the ability, to want to make better grades?" Tillack said.

At the least, she said, the district should consider changing its honor roll formula so that students who have grades below a certain level aren't eligible.

"I'm all for it being harder, as opposed to easier," Tillack said. "The overall thing is, if a child knows they can do the minimum and get by, what kind of message does that send about the other areas in their life?"

Jeffrey S. Solochek can be reached at jsolochek@tampabay.com.

Low grades temper Dade City mother's enthusiasm over son's honor roll performance 11/12/13 [Last modified: Tuesday, November 12, 2013 10:26pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Clearwater eyes hiring new downtown director within two months

    CLEARWATER — Now that the city director tasked with revitalizing downtown has resigned after his arrest on a battery charge during Oktoberfest, City Manager Bill Horne said the goal is to not leave the position vacant long.

    Clearwater Assistant City Manager  Micah Maxwell will oversee downtown until the city hires a replacement for Seth Taylor.
  2. Tampa Bay's Top 100 Workplaces deadline extended to Nov. 17

    Business

    Think you work at one of the best places in Tampa Bay? You've got a little more time to make a pitch.

    Penny Hoarder and Gregory, Sharer & Stuart were among those at an event in Tampa last May honoring winners of the Tampa Bay Times Top Workplaces awards. Nominations are now open for this year.  
[OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times]
  3. Little separates McElwain and Muschamp eras of futility at Florida

    College

     Florida Gators head coach Jim McElwain watches the second quarter of the Florida Gators game against Texas A&M, at Ben Hill Griffin Stadium, in Gainesville.
  4. Tampa-based Checkers testing delivery, aims for record expansion

    Retail

    TAMPA — Tampa-based Checkers Drive-In Restaurants continues to fly under the radar compared to dominant burger chains like McDonald's and Burger King.

    Checkers Franchisee Shaji Joseph, of Tampa, hoses down the front walkway of his store at 6401 Park Boulevard, Pinellas Park. The business has a new look including signage and exterior tile. One drive through has been eliminated for an outdoor dining area, right. Joseph owns nine Checkers and is planning to open his tenth in Tampa.
[SCOTT KEELER   |   Times ]
  5. Advice for presidents from military families they've tried to console

    War

    One family returned the letter because it was full of errors. Another was left cold when the letter they got screamed "robo-pen." Still another was puzzled to find 17 copies of their letter in the mailbox.

    Army Chief Warrant Officer 3 Aaron Cowan, 37, was killed in a helicopter training accident in South Korea on Feb. 26, 2005. [Courtesy of Kari Cowan]