Saturday, November 18, 2017

Ryan Fitzpatrick vs. Josh McCown: Comparing the vagabond quarterbacks


When the Buccaneers host the Jets on Sunday, it won’t be the first time Ryan Fitzpatrick and Josh McCown have gone head-to-head. In fact, this will be the third straight season they’ve played against each other. Fitzpatrick’s Jets got the better of McCown’s Browns both times.

Okay, so it’s not Brady vs. Manning. It’s more like beige vs. khaki. Really.

See whether you can tell the difference.

Josh McPatrick or Ryan Fitzcown?

Their career stats are virtually indistinguishable.

Quarterback AQuarterback B
Win percentage0.4010.319
Completion percentage59.860.4
Touchdown percentage4.33.8
Interception percentage3.43.2
Yards per attempt6.76.8
Quarterback rating79.980.2

(Answer: Quarterback A is Fitzpatrick, B is McCown)

How’d we get here?

Fitzpatrick and McCown have been all over the map. They’ve called 13 NFL cities home but haven’t stayed anywhere longer than four seasons. Their former teams haven’t missed them, but they haven’t exactly been better off, either.


TeamSeasonsWho he replacedWho replaced him
St. Louis2005-2006Marc BulgerMarc Bulger
Cincinnati2007-2008Carson PalmerCarson Palmer
Buffalo2009-2012Trent EdwardsEJ Manuel
Tennessee2013Jake LockerJake Locker
Houston2014Matt SchaubBrian Hoyer
N.Y. Jets2015-2016Geno SmithJosh McCown
Tampa Bay2017Jameis Winstone_SEmD


TeamSeasonsWho he replacedWho replaced him
Arizona2002-2005Jeff Blake (2003), Kurt Warner (2005)Shaun King (2004), Kurt Warner (2005)
Detroit2006Did not attempt a pass.
Oakland2007Daunte CulpepperJaMarcus Russell
Carolina2008-2009Jake DelhommeJake Delhomme
Played in United Football League in 2010.
Chicago2011-2013Jay CutlerJay Cutler
Tampa Bay2014Mike GlennonJameis Winston
Cleveland2015-2016Connor ShawAustin Davis
N.Y. Jets2017Ryan Fitzpatricke_SEmD

They’re not eating Ws

The 20 lowest win percentages among active quarterbacks (minimum 16 games started):

Blaine Gabbert0.225
Brandon Weeden0.240
Mike Glennon0.273
Colt McCoy0.280
Terrelle Pryor0.300
Blake Bortles0.302
Josh McCown0.319
EJ Manuel0.333
Chad Henne0.340
Kellen Clemens0.381
Geno Smith0.400
Ryan Fitzpatrick0.401
Jameis Winston0.425
Derek Anderson0.426
Sam Bradford0.431
Brian Hoyer0.432
Case Keenum0.433
Matt Cassel0.444
Matthew Stafford0.470
Marcus Mariota0.471

Contact Thomas Bassinger at Follow @tometrics.


Region football: Clearwater Central Catholic 37, Calvary Christian 10

CLEARWATER — The ice bath ensued for Clearwater Central Catholic coach Chris Harvey after the Marauders’ 37-10 victory over Calvary Christian in Friday’s Class 3A region final. The win placed the Marauders (11-0) in their fifth state tournament since...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Region football: Plant 22, Viera 18

Region football: Plant 22, Viera 18

MELBOURNE — With 1 yard separating Plant from an incredible come-from-behind victory, or a devastating defeat, it all came down to a matter of trust.And for Panthers coach Robert Weiner, there was no one he would put more faith in to get that 1 yard ...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Region football: Armwood 22, Hillsborough 0

Region football: Armwood 22, Hillsborough 0

SEFFNER — Hillsborough conquered one nemesis with last week’s win over Class 6A defending state finalist Lake Gibson, the team that knocked the Terriers out of the playoffs in the first round a year ago.But there was an even bigger stumbling block to...
Updated: 4 hours ago

Region football: Ocala Vanguard 35, Mitchell 31

NEW PORT RICHEY — The start wasn’t quite befitting of a playoff game between undefeated teams, but the end of Friday’s war between Ocala Vanguard and Mitchell certainly was.Like last year’s Class 6A regional semifinal, the Mustangs held a three-point...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Region football: Green Cove Springs Clay 52, Zephyrhills 49

Region football: Green Cove Springs Clay 52, Zephyrhills 49

ZEPHYRHILLS — For Zephyrhills, Friday night’s Class 5A region semifinal against Green Cove Springs Clay was doomed by 12 bad minutes. The Bulldogs led by four points at halftime but allowed 28 unanswered points in the third quarter and were not able ...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Region football: Lakewood 20, Jesuit 7

Region football: Lakewood 20, Jesuit 7

ST. PETERSBURG — Lakewood came into Friday’s playoff game knowing its defense had to help control field position against Jesuit. The Spartans (9-1) left Friday’s game with a ticket to Immokalee for a region final — and six Tigers (6-5) turnovers en r...
Updated: 4 hours ago

Region football: Tampa Bay Tech 42, Palmetto 26

TAMPA — Another Friday night, another offensive explosion.Tampa Bay Tech’s offense continued its torrid pace and quarterback Michael Penix Jr. accounted for five total touchdowns as the Titans rolled past Palmetto 42-26 in a Class 7A, Region 3 semifi...
Updated: 4 hours ago

Region football: Cambridge Christian 50, Indian Rocks Christian 14

TAMPA — The Cambridge Christian offense was clicking, and quarterback Jaylin Jackson couldn’t seem to be stopped. Still, as the second quarter clock dwindled, Indian Rocks Christian was hanging around.So with just more than a minute left in the half,...
Updated: 4 hours ago

Region football: Naples 24, Largo 0

NAPLES — In a game between two teams that had never met with a lot on the line, the Naples defense came up with one of its best efforts against Largo on Friday night.The Golden Eagles limited the Packers to 117 yards of offense in a 24-0 triumph in t...
Updated: 4 hours ago

Region football: Lakeland 52, Wiregrass Ranch 0

LAKELAND — It has been a historic season for the Wiregrass Ranch Bulls football team, which made consecutive playoff appearances for the first time, won its most games ever and experienced its first playoff victory.If this were a movie, the final sce...
Updated: 4 hours ago